So I went to see Superman Returns with my girlfriend Anna’s family (see, Anna, I mentioned you on the blog).
I’ll try to keep this review both brief and as spoiler-free as possible (edit: Totally failed on the "brief" element). Cutting to the chase, I thought it wasn’t good and wasn’t bad. It was just there. Let us engage in bullet points!
- The movie was HEAVILY influenced by other superhero movies. Mainly Spiderman, but even though the film is supposedly set after the original Superman movie, the plot is so similar to the original movie as to be distracting at some points
- Brandon Routh was okay. I don’t know why people are picking on him so much. I agree he’s just doing a Christopher Reeves impression, but it was a decent enough impression and I thought he nailed the Superman voice quite well.
- Kate Bosworth’s impression of Natalie Portman in Star Wars was spot on. That is to say, she either can’t act or may be deaf and did not hear the director shout "Action!" at the start of each scene. Add to this the fact that she’s basically 14 years old and weighs under 100 pounds and is playing a 30 year old with a kid and this becomes one of the all-time "blah" casting choices.
A Brief Interlude:
Bryan Singer: Okay, Kate, in this scene, you’re upset. Superman is in trouble, and you’re unsure of both your and his feelings towards each other. And, ACTION!
Bryan Singer: CUT! Okay, Kate, see, what I wanted you to do, was pretend, or "act" as they say, like you were sad. What you did was remain completely motionless without changing your expression. Let’s try that again with some movement. ACTION! No, no, Kate, I don’t think a fake British accent will class this scene up. Yes, I loved Renee Zellwegger in that too, but let’s stick with this for now. Don’t worry about doing an accent or using human inflections or anything. People will love your flat line readings of every moment in the film.
Bryan Singer: (to stage hand) Maybe we could computer animate most of her scenes…
- The film was not nearly fun enough. Now I’ll say this right now, I’m not a big Superman fan. I think he’s a really goofy superhero along the lines of the ones you make up when you’re 7 in the schoolyard. "Well my superhero is super strong and he shoots lasers and he jump really high and fly!" But the reason the Spiderman movies at least sort of work is that we not only like Spiderman as a character, but he always seems to come up short. It’s just like Indiana Jones. We love him because he does all this stuff just to make it through somewhere and then the idol gets stolen from him. And Spiderman gets the shit knocked out of him over and over again during every scene. But Superman is too strong for that, so all the action scenes in the middle of the film are just boring. He’s not in danger. They don’t really involve the plot, and they’re all CG. Many of the shots were slow and paired with big rising music, as if to shout to you "This is a big deal! This is Superman! This is a big deal!" It felt a lot like the modern Star Wars films in the way they were filled with self-important "look at me, I’m an important franchise!" moments.
- The action scenes were scarred by a fundamental problem: Seeing Superman push really hard while flying is meaningless. He’s not pushing off anything, and we have no visible indication of how he can fly harder, so it always seems like he just struggles for a while and then somehow flies harder and succeeds. They use this effect over and over and over again, and it’s just not that interesting.
- There were plenty of plotholes, but I don’t care a ton about that. I care that the movie felt slow and plodding at many points and that the ending dragged and felt unsatisfying. Even with the big soaring end, it felt like Superman was never tested and didn’t grow in the film. He acts like things have changed a lot at the end, but it feels somewhat false and hollow.
- The obsession with making this a franchise demanded an ending that wasn’t really an ending. The film is long but refuses to seriously change any of the main characters because all of them are under contract for a sequel.
Final Grade: 6.5 / 10
Certainly not awful, but not really good either. I could definitely understand someone really liking it, if they really liked the character, but for me it was just an adequate film that desperately wanted to be so much more than that.